The third Potentials workshop brings together students, entrepreneurs and other professionals from the craft and design
fields from Namibia and Finland. The Potentials workshops aim to nurture leadership and entrepreneurship by
developing design management skills in a hands-on environment...
The third Potentials workshop brings together students, entrepreneurs and other professionals from the craft and design fields from Namibia and Finland. The Potentials workshops aim to nurture leadership and entrepreneurship by developing design management skills in a hands-on environment... The workshop takes place from 1-5 June 2009 at the Pambili studios and Studio 77 in Windhoek, Namibia.
PAMBILI ASSOCIATION: The Pambili Association was founded in 2005 to introduce the concept of social design in
certain Namibian communities. Since then, the Association has been involved in design and craft training and marketing.
Pambili follows the approach of educating and empowering young designers, craft designers, producers, students and
professionals so that they become aware, involved and active in social design issues. The association’s activities focus
on fashion, jewellery and interior design activities and product development.
Pambili’s vision is to have a strong impact on future design training, mentoring and research in Na-mibia through
networking, exchange opportunities, and hands-on activities. An overall objective is to ensure that Namibian communities
and young Namibian designers benefit trough the production of quality design products that answer the demands of both
the local and foreign markets in order to enable business and trade opportunities for the communities, designers and
Pambili Association itself.
POTENTIALS 3 – DESIGN ACTION – DESIGN MANAGEMENT
Design leadership is a proactive method of design. It focuses on creating a concrete future vision for a company.
Scenario-based design is one of the central tools in creating the future vision. The future vision is communicated through
a concrete action plan for a company. Design Management includes visual communication of a company’s brand, identity
and values.
The third Potentials workshop brings together students, entrepreneurs and other professionals from the craft and design
fields. The workshop takes place from June 1 to June 5, 2009 at the Pambili studios and Studio 77 in Windhoek,
Namibia.
The two previous Potentials workshops had a more theoretical approach, concentrating on design theo-ries and
concepts. In Potentials 3, a practical level has been implemented where concepts are developed further. The participants
will create designs, mock-ups and prototypes with their newly acquired theoreti-cal and practical knowledge. They will
work either individually or in groups, depending on the task and station. The tutors will guide the creation process in the
form of discussions, asking relevant questions, providing different perspectives and making their expertise available.
AIMS OF POTENTIALS 3
Strengthening networks:
Bringing together different actors of the art, craft and design domains
Support national micro-entrepreneurship by producing theoretical and practical knowledge:
Developing design concepts that can serve Namibian community-based craft projects
Introducing and developing practical project management tools
Use design management to strengthen the practice of Namibian craft and design entrepreneurs, projects, associations
and guilds:
Developing new product concepts and implementing design management tools in order to become Namibian design
leaders instead of design followers.
ACTION STATIONS
The ‘action station’ concept that has been used in the previous Potentials workshops has been recog-nised to be an
effective method for people from different disciplines to network, share ideas, study theory and develop practical skills
together. The method has many advantages. Each station hosts producers, students and designers with different
backgrounds. They learn from each other by sharing knowledge and experiences from the different disciplines that they
represent.
The action station groups have great advantages due its interdisciplinary approach to the given tasks and in problem
solving. Another advantage is that there is interaction between different action stations as all are working under the same
general theme and common goals. The first goal is to solve design problems in the various action stations according to
the common theoretical theme ‘Design Management’, and secondly to produce practical results and prepare them for an
exhibition. The workshop consists of eight different action stations, facilitated by 14 tutors from both Finland and
Namibia. The tutors provide insights into various craft-design management tools and techniques.
They host coherent stations familiarising the participants with theoretical and practical aspects on the overall theme –
Design Management. On day one all participants go through an orientation process in which they rotate through all eight
sta-tions where the tutors present the theoretical background and practical tasks of their allocated stations. On day two
the participants are divided into pre-selected groups in which they will stay for the remainder of the workshop.
The action stations and tutors are:
Suvi Matinaro, fashion designer, Marimekko Corporation, Finland
Jewellery design
Attila Giersch, jewellery designer, Tameka Design, Namibia
Sanna Latva-Ranta, jewellery designer, Finland
Saara Tuhkanen (assistant), metal work and jewellery graduate student, Savonia University of Applied Sciences,
Kuopio Academy of Design, Finland
Richard Kayili (assistant), College of the Arts
Business gift design
Laura Pokela, designer, Finland
Graphic design
Niina Turtola, graphic designer, Finland
Exhibition design
Reetta Kerola, industrial design student, Savonia University of Applied Sciences, Kuopio Acad-emy of Design, Finland
Riikka Mäkinen, interior and furniture design graduate student, Kuopio Academy of Design, Finland
Textile design
Tarja Wallius, designer and artist, Tarja Wallius Design, Finland
Design awareness
Hanna Peräkylä, design student, Finland
Maria Caley, fashion designer and lecturer, University of Namibia
Media and Performance
Taina Kontio, artist, Finland
POTENTIALS 3 EXHIBITION
The workshop process culminates with an exhibition, which will showcase the outcomes to the public. The exhibition will
travel trough different locations starting in Windhoek at Studio 77, going to the Wind-hoek College of Arts and eventually
travelling to Finland, where some of the outcomes will potentially be exhibited at the Helinä Rautavaara museum.
OPENING ADDRESS BY CATHY McROBERTS
DESIGN MANAGEMENT
Last week I was invited to open the Potentials 3 workshop with a few words explaining the concept of design
management. I said that I would be happy to do so but had to confess that I had not come across the juxtaposition of the
word ‘design’ with the word ‘management’ in Namibia before. At first, the term ‘design management appears’ to be simple
and straight-forward but the more I thought about it the less simple and straightforward it became. The following
questions came into my head:
Is it the act of designing that is to be managed?
Is it the production of the designed object that is to be managed?
Is it the finding of a market for the design service that is to be managed?
Is it the marketing of the designed object that is to be managed?
Or is it a combination of all of these?
So I thought about the two words separately at first to try to get closer to the meaning.
Design
The term ‘design’ is quite difficult to pin down. Design, in its pure sense is abstract, because design is all about ideas. A
designer is a person who has ideas, usually but not always, about how things should look. The designer will usually try to
develop his or her ideas by writing about them or by turning them into drawings or plans. So design, in its purest sense is
to do with inspiration, thought and also feeling.
A design, once it appears on paper or on the computer is a transitory thing, in other words it is a thought that is on the
way to being something.
Can you buy design? Yes, of course. You can buy design in the form of a design service or a consultation such as the
advice that you can purchase from an interior designer. Otherwise you can buy an object that has been designed.
Are all objects designed? I would say that all objects that have been made by people are indeed de-signed. Some may
be in my opinion, badly designed; some may be in my opinion, well designed. My opinion and your opinion may be quite
different. This highlights the issue of quality that inevitably comes up when we talk about design. Design can be good or
bad, in other words it has value.
Who then decides whether a design is good or bad? In the case of most designed objects it is the person who buys the
object; in other words the market. If I design an object that I intend to sell and all of my friends tell me how lovely it is but
nobody wants to buy it then the design has failed. So the designer needs to understand the ‘taste’ of the market that the
object is intended for.
So this means that a designer does not only consider his or her original inspiration when designing but the taste and
desires of the market for which the designed object is intended.
So I would ask you, who buys the design service or the designed objects that you are selling? How well do you
understand your market?
On to management
Management is to do with control and is a very straightforward term. It has to do with creating workable structures, with
organisation and with efficiency. It is a term most often used in connection with business or other organisations. Efficient
management will make a business or any organisation work better.
Many designers are bad managers. They concentrate on the creation of beautiful ideas and beautiful ob-jects and do not
have the organisational skills to manage their business activities.
In fact, marrying the term ‘design’ with the term ‘management’ appears at first sight to be a union of op-posites.
Now those of us who try to encourage the blossoming of creativity in the people who we work with have learnt that one
way to do it is by the clashing of opposing concepts.
So what is the creative force that is unleashed by the joining together of design and management?
From the outline of the Potentials 3 workshop, the term appears to refer mostly to the activities of product development
and marketing with the added consideration of the concept of branding, which is part of marketing.
Product development, in other words, the concept of creating or adapting the design of a product in order to make it
acceptable to an identified market, should be well understood by most of the participants of this workshop.
Marketing, in other words, providing the right product at the right time in the right way and at the right price to an
identified customer should also be well understood.
Branding might be new to some of you, so let me talk a little bit about this.
In a recent edition of Business Week writer, Karen Klein, gathered together some thoughts on branding. She said that all
producers should define their brand identity —I n other words their product's ‘personality’ — before they spend a cent on
advertising or marketing.
She said that branding is something that happens before the producer starts to think about how the mar-ket will be
reached. Branding is about creating a personality for your product and about presenting your product as the only
possible solution to the needs of your customers. If you brand your product successfully your customers will even be
prepared to pay extra for your brand.
A brand is to do with what your business stands for. What is your business about? How does your prod-uct make your
customer feel? How does it relate to your customers lifestyle? Does it make life easier? More glamorous? More exciting?
More secure?
Branding is also about the promise that you make to your customers and your promise should be different from that of
your competitors. Do you promise quality? Peace of mind? Desirability? Status?
Klein says that a brand creates an image in the mind of the consumer. It says something is different at your firm,
something worth more than business as usual. If you are only selling a product your customers will choose solely on the
basis of price or quality. If you've got a brand, you're selling a lifestyle and you can sell anything you want.
I personally find branding to be a very exciting activity to be involved in. It is something that my students very much enjoy
doing and something that encourages them to become even more creative when designing products for their own brand.
In Namibia we are not very good at creating our own brands. I hope that as a result of the activities of the Potentials 3
workshop, you will have the inspiration to design your own exciting products, create the most exciting brand identities
and market these products successfully in Namibia and beyond.
I wish you all very well.
ABOUT Cathy McROBERTS
Cathy McRoberts was born in the UK and educated as an artist in London.
After graduating, she practised as a textile designer in the UK, France and Italy. While teaching in schools and colleges
in London she continued to produce textile designs on a freelance basis and travelled with design collections to New
York and Italy.
On moving to Bulawayo, Zimbabwe in 1988, she taught in the Art Department of Bulawayo Polytechnic and regularly
exhibited textiles and paintings in Bulawayo and Harare.
After Namibian independence in 1990, she settled in Windhoek and currently lectures in textiles at the University of
Namibia’s Visual Arts Department.
Her particular interests are in the production, use and social significance of textiles in Africa.
During the next four days, we are publishing reports from different action stations, including some amateur video
interviews with some of the participants who share their personal experiences. Today we feature the activities of the
jewellery and fashion action stations.
The jewellery design action station’s task focusses on creating new jewellery pieces with a distinctive Namibian identity.
Personal memories and symbols of a culture are immaterial values attached to jewellery. These aspects can be
emphasised in the design process. The jewellery design station aims to provide tools for designing and making jewellery
with individual and national relevance. Products with a distinctive Namibian identity can be an asset when marketing
them to specific consumer groups.
Design management in the jewellery field is about realising the needs of customers, being able to apply the information
into the design process and in the end, being able to produce and market the products. The emphasis of the Namibian
craft scene is changing from production-orientated to a more design-orientated practice. Producers have to consider
ways to add value to their products. Original products will have competitiveness in the marketplace.
The jewellery station started with two theoretical surveys. The objectives of the surveys were to collect data that can be
applied in the product development process. The first survey mapped the desires and values that people attach to their
jewellery. All 65 participants listed things that can be attached to wearing and possessing jewellery. This data was be
gathered in a form of a game. The purpose of the second survey was to establish the meanings of colour: what they
indicate and symbolise and what phenomena’s they are related to. The participants listed national and personal
meanings of colours that will be used as information for the practical work at the station.
The participants of the jewellery station are encouraged to use the data from the surveys in the design process. Design
choices for colours, forms, materials, textures and techniques will be discussed during the design phase and the surveys
and its applications will be used as a tool for developing marketing plans for the final products. At the end of the
workshop, the products will be exhibited with the unique stories and inspirations of the designers.
At the fashion action station we study the ’image’ of fashion. A single fashion image can communicate at various levels,
but it will only do so if it is well planned. Photography is an essential tool for determining trends, brands, looks and values
in the fashion industry. The ’image’ of fashion is a controversial and contradictory subject: It can carry positive and
negative messages about lifestyle, health and ethics. Often the fashion industry has presented itself in a poor light by
making ’decadent behaviour’ seem desirable. The aims of focussing on the ’image’ of fashion is to make the workshop
participants aware of the powerful messages that fashion can communicate and to allow them to discover how it can
help build a stronger cultural self-esteem which can be used as a tool for empowerment.
The participants were set a task to prepare for their own photoshoots. To assist them in finding a personal focus for
designing systematiclly, they had to collect images and create collages that illustrate the ’Why’, ’What’ and ’for Whom’.
The collages act as tools to ensure that all end products have a background, a story behind them and a reason to exist.
The collages will function as a ’directory’ for all people involved in the task at hand: the designer, photographer, make-up
artist, hair stylist and the model.
’BACKSEAT STORIES’ Day 2
The video clips are not of best quality, but we think that the stories and true voices of the participants are very special.
ACTION STATION: MEDIA AND PERFORMANCE
Tutor: Taina Kontio
taina91@hotmail.com
The media and performance action station offers participants an opportunity to express themselves through new digital
media. As an outcome of the workshop, participants produce a short film or a video installation on three screens. They
choose three elements – soundscape, environment and people – to describe their life in modern Namibia.
From a creative point of view, participants are required to contemplate what it means to be a young Namibian as well as
visualising their future. At the beginning of the workshop they had to choose a colour that represents their personality
and identity, which they are required to apply in all aspects of the process.
In addition to developing their creative skills, participants also learn about the production and management process of
filmmaking. They learn about the writing of a synopsis, screenwriting, directing and camerawork as well as effective
teamwork. The method of working together also puts emphasis on unconventional gender roles and empowerment of
women.
ACTION STATION: TEXTILE DESIGN Tutor: Tarja Wallius
tarja@tarjawallius.fi
In the textile station the participants work with basic textile techniques and learn to understand that you can make
impressive fabrics by implementing basic techniques. The participants will be introduced to the textile design process
which includes conceptualising, sketching, selecting techniques which suit the design and finally, rationalising the design
by telling the story behind it. Continuous discourse between the tutor and the participants will assist the participants to
grasp the process.
The design management aspect in the textile station is about realising that you can use uncomplicated equipment to
create impressive textiles. The textile techniques which are in use are:
Painting with different brushes and rollers
Printing with simple things which you can find in your environment such as organic materials and found objects,
Printing with paper and plastic stencils
The task which is given to the participants is to consider their Namibian identity and to include some memories or
meaningful things from their past and present lives in their conceptualisation and to use these ideas in their designs.
Without knowing your past you can’t recognise the presence and build the future.
’BACKSEAT STORIES’ Day 3
The video clips are not of best quality, but we think that the stories and true voices of the participants are very special.
ACTION STATION: BUSINESS GIFT
Tutors:
Laura Pokela laura@designmigration.com
Melanie Harteveld Becker, mach20@mweb.com.na
The Business gift action station offers participants an opportunity to practice a design process driven by a real client
company’s needs. Trough the process, the participants can understand the essence of design as a strategy and a tool.
The designers will create proposals that are reflecting to given information about the client company and their personal
impressions of the brand. The action station offers a market opportunity and income generation possibilities for the
designers and makers of the chosen products, which will be produced by Pambili and suitable craft producing
communities.
The station will introduce case examples of business gift design from Finland and business gift culture in general. After
the background insights the participants will produce proposals in small design teams and use the given information as
an outline. Each day the design process goes one step further, following a set plan. The aim is to build proposals, in
which each detail is well considered and result of the teams thinking process. The proposals will be presented to the
client by the teams, which will give good experience on presentation skills. The client will select a design/s that are most
suitable for the company’s needs and reflective of the values and style of the brand.
The participants will be encouraged to utilise locally available materials, techniques and know-how. The chosen design/s
could spread the benefits from the central business focused context to both urban and rural craft producing communities
and individual entrepreneurs. If the client wishes, the social and cultural aspects could be attached to the products as
background stories.
ACTION STATION: DESIGN AWARENESS Tutors:
Hanna Peräkylä, hanna.perakyla@taik.fi
Maria Caley, mcaley@unam.na [white text]
Design management is about seeing the bigger picture and being aware of the different working and production phases
related to products. At the design awareness action station participants are asked: How can ecological, social and ethical
issues be taken in consideration when designing a product?
The participants discuss the life cycle of products and the impact that production has on the environment. The aim is to
question material solutions: Can products be made out of recycled materials? Can the designer totally delete the earlier
function of a material? Do recycled materials have to be recognised in products? Is recycling adding value to an object?
If the designer is aware of the production phases and the ecological footprint of a product, can he/she use it as an asset
in marketing? Attaching background information about the designer, production and materials are valuable facts for
clients.
The design awareness action station is trying to find answers for these questions trough the practical working process.
The participants create hand-made prototypes from local re-used materials. The working process leads participants to a
discussion: What is the meaning of design?
’BACKSEAT STORIES’ Day 4
The video clips are not of best quality, but we think that the stories and true voices of the participants are very special.
The graphic design action station discusses the meaning and importance of graphic design, the use of typography and
image, understanding visual culture and the context of design management. The action station gives examples of
graphic design projects in the field of design management, posters as a tool of graphic design and other examples of
graphic design. Understanding one’s own visual culture, means looking closely at the surrounding environment.
The participants will make flyers and posters to promote the Potentials 3 Workshop. The themes and vis-ual language to
be used in the posters and flyers will come from participants own life in Windhoek and the workshop itself. The colours
for posters and flyers follow the colour scheme of Potentials 3 Workshop. The produced materials are self-expression of
the participants and are executed by hand instead of computer.
The exhibition design action station concentrates on designing the Potentials 3 exhibition, which presents the works
produced during the five-day workshop. The exhibition is a showcase of all the outcomes from the various action
stations. It creates a link that connects the Namibian public and the participating local artists, craftsmen and designers. It
is a showcase of new product ideas, talents and current Namibian design know-how. Therefore communication,
accessibility and creating an interesting presentation of the exhibition are focal aspects discussed on the exhibition
action station. Designing the Potentials 3 exhibition provides a versatile insight for the participants regarding the planning
of an exhibition and creating a functional, attractive and marketable ensemble.
The participants create a suitable context for all the exhibited materials. They will learn to promote the different aspects
of every station. It is important to understand the essence of all produced ideas and artefacts, and consider how to
communicate it to the exhibition visitors. Design management component entails balancing the exhibition props, the
exhibited materials and the interior of the exhibition space.
The participants question how the environment reflects on designs and how it can be represented to the public. The
exhibition elements and structures are built with locally available materials. The participants seek new ways to turn local
and recycled materials into a new, interesting exhibition scene with a Namibian.
’BACKSEAT STORIES’ Day 5
The video clips are not of best quality, but we think that the stories and true voices of the participants are very special.
The five-day Pambili Potentials 3 Workshop attracted 65 participants and 13 tutors at Studio 77 in Windhoek, Namibia.
One of the aims of Potentials 3 was to bring different players of the art, craft and design domains together. The
participants were members of different community-based craft projects, students from the University of Namibia and the
College of the Arts, craft trainees and entrepreneurs. This melting pot also included the tutors who are designers,
professionals and design students, both from Namibia and Finland.
Potentials 3 turned out to be an efficient working platform for many disciplines and media. Participants and tutors from
the various action stations not only cross-communicated but also collaborated on various tasks. The participants had
different levels of skills and knowledge and the tutors witnessed the development of many design ideas while participants
advised each other drawing on their personal perspectives, skills and knowledge. Students with a stronger background in
design processes co-worked with craft producers who had stronger technical skills. This resulted in skills-sharing and
cross fertilisation with regards to the design management process.
One of the biggest benefits of the workshop was the development of networking and participants continuously shared
contact details, which will most likely lead to future co-operation. The participants all learned new design and thinking
skills and they develop a broad array of concepts and prototypes, which raised their awareness of design management
principles. The principle idea was to stress the importance of design leadership and design management and the role
they play in sustainable development.
OPENING OF THE POTENTIALS 3 EXHIBITION.
Jewellery design
Jewellery is not mere jewellery. There should always a meaning behind it. The participants of this action station were
guided to understand the symbolism found in objects of personal adornment. Participants were very motivated and
concentrated throughout the workshop week. Participants were introduced to new materials and techniques in a very
short period of time after which they went on to develop prototypes. Although some had never used the introduced
materials or techniques, they managed to produce impressive and colourful neckpieces. At the end of the workshop
participants were eager to learn what the other participants have achieved. Some participants developed more than one
prototype in the four days, which confirmed their interest in what they had learned. All products designed and produced
in this action station were based on the designer’s personal memories and stories.
Fashion design
During the workshop week the participants were introduced to conceptualisation and planning of a fashion shoot or
presentation. The participants aimed to achieve deep conceptualisation levels and they managed to achieve exactly
what the action station’s tutors had hope for. As a result of the process they created realistic collection ideas and strong
personal fashion identities. The participants clearly understood the importance of careful planning and preparation. On
the photo shoot day the photographer, Charl du Preez, congratulated the participants for being better prepared than
some professionals he has worked with in the past. Hopefully the associations made during the photo shoot day will help
the participants on their journey to become skilled and professional designers. The fashion action station tutor, Suvi
Matinaro, stated: “I have learned that fashion doesn't begin and stop with the garment. It goes further than the physical.”
Media and performance
The participants in the media action station learned much about the importance of teamwork. They were exposed to
basic technical skills and developed an understanding of basic media equipment, which triggered many essential
discussions were future possibilities visualised. The discussions about the rights and equality of women in both African
society and the media industry were particularly interesting as well as human rights issues and life during and after
apartheid. The participants were eager to discuss their possibilities in entering the media industry by starting their own
businesses. One of the outcomes that were identified related to access (or lack thereof) to technical equipment, which
spawned the idea of establishing Finnish media centres in Namibia sometime in the future.
Textile station
The aim of the textile action station was to learn how to make impressive fabrics using different techniques. A number of
the participants were familiar with some of the techniques introduced, while other techniques were new to them. The
presentations and discussions in the textile station strengthened the technical skills and confidence of participants. They
learned that design originates from inspiration that is turned into a concept. The theme at the textile station was the
development of a vernacular Namibian identity. One participant took a motif from traditional jewellery that was printed on
2X1 meter cotton textile. Participants drew inspiration from their everyday lives for their textile designs.
Business gift design
The station offered a deep insight into business gift design, aiming to answer a challenging brief given by two Namibian
partner companies: Corporate Connections and MTC. The participants created several product ideas, graphic elements
and mock-ups based on guidelines that aimed at answer the needs of both customer companies. The most important
outcomes of this action station was the growing awareness of the participants about what business gifts are, what their
purpose is and how to answer customer needs for specific or diverse target audiences. The participants’ design solutions
varied from small-scale handmade items to products that could be manufactured by large-scale industrial processes. The
concepts were presented to the customer companies on the last workshop day and the workshop organisers envisage
that it will lead to further development of certain suitable product ideas and eventually benefit the designer and producer
communities in Namibia.
Design awareness
The design awareness action station’s participants produced several different prototypes and finished art pieces out of
founded and recycled material. Many innovative ideas developed from the working process and through constant
problem solving. One of the most used materials was plastic which they molded by melting several components together.
Plastic bags and bottles being accessible for all were transformed into new products. Participants learned to combine
different recycled materials by producing functional objects. Through collecting the material by themselves, participants
gained knowledge of recycling and became more aware of the material and how the production choices will impact on
the environment. Prototypes are exhibited with the used material details with the aim to introduce the process to the
public.
Graphic design
Participants produced hand-made flyers and posters to promote the exhibition. Doing design by hand makes the creative
thinking and implementation process more visible and tangible. Conceptual thinking and sketching is as important as
design itself. Participants grasped the idea of design management to follow certain given rules, as for example in this
case the Potentials color scheme. Through examples of graphic design we discussed the important role of a designer
and designers’ understanding of goals of the work designed as well as the visual culture surrounding us in our everyday
lives. Tracing letters, typography, painting and using markers makes thinking visible and in the end communicates a
specific message.
Exhibition design
Participants of the exhibition design action station developed a realisation for the importance of planning and taking into
consideration the exhibition interior, layout and decoration of the space. The exhibition station linked all the stations
together under one roof and the participants interacted with all the Potentials 3 action stations. Multiple possibilities of the
exhibition displays were investigated and considered through practical examples of different material, colour and lighting
usage. The station aimed to design an interesting and tempting exhibition entrance. The designed an entertaining
experience by planning the layout of the exhibition in harmonious sections where the outcomes of the workshop was
grouped according to themes and action stations. The props and set up was designed and created by using recycled
materials found at a local dumpsite.
SUMMER 2009/10 FASHION TRENDS ON SHOW AT SSAFW +/-
Fashionistas gathered at Sanlam SA Fashion Week (SSAFW) from 2-4 April at The Forum Turbine Hall, Johannesburg, where the Summer 2009/10 collections of 34 new and established designers were introduced at South Africa’s premier fashion showcase. Three of DESIGN> magazine’s contributors, Fatima Cassim, Karuna Pillay and Anri Theron share their blow-by-blow (no pun intended) impressions...
As an avid fan of South African fashion, I was delighted to be asked to write my first fashion reportage on the 13th annual
SSAFW Summer 09/10 collections. Since its inception, SSAFW has become South Africa’s most visible forum
showcasing the country’s top and emerging fashion designers. Bearing this in mind, I was certainly not disappointed by
either the venue or the shows which I attended. To begin with, Turbine Hall is an interesting and very appropriate choice
of venue. In contrast to others, such as the Sandton Convention Centre where previous Fashion Weeks have been held,
Turbine Hall’s industrial architecture with its raw and almost gritty interior, as well as the split-levels, provided an
interesting dimension to the ambience of the shows, often enhancing or juxtaposing collections in a positive manner.
Once seated in the main hall, the evening’s programme kicked off with a show by two well-established labels, Amanda
Laird Cherry and Lunar. Amanda Laird Cherry’s collection was characterised by a strong reference to the idea of
wrapping. By her own admission, Amanda Laird Cherry stated that the collection stemmed from her native KwaZulu
Natal and the different ways in which people wrap fabric around their bodies. Apart from the clothing, an interesting
reference to African rites of passage and ceremonies in the show were the handcrafted ethnic necklaces worn by the
models. In light of her influence, it was refreshing to see the use of a monochromatic palette. Overall, the multi-textured
layerings on offer were presented in simple and asymmetrical silhouettes which echoed a strong tribal influence.
Like Amanda Laird Cherry, the Lunar label adopted a neutral palette of predominantly white and grey. Formal pieces
such as jackets and vests were detailed with visible stitching, thus rendering them as natural and ‘farm-like work wear’.
This ‘farm-like’ reference was also evident in a pair of johphur pants and sling bags accessorising the models on the
ramp. Furthermore, the choice of fabrics such as linen gauze, silk, and cotton were also in keeping with the natural and
earthy underpinnings of the collection. Designer Karen Ter Morshuizen’s latest offering for Lunar did not live up to my
personal expectations based on some of Lunar’s previous collections which I have admired for its innovation and bold
statements. Nonetheless, the label’s sensitivity and concern for environmental issues remains admirable.
For the second show of the evening, the catwalk was shared by the lingerie label Ruby by Robyn Lidsky and the label,
Two by sister-duo, Caren and Gina Waldman. Both collections injected some colour onto the catwalk, in contrast to the
other shows on the day. Despite their respective fashion lines, it was interesting to note a striking similarity between the
two labels. Both Ruby and Two had a strong ‘floral’ presence in their collections. According to Robyn Lidsky, she was
inspired by seeing the Nothern Cape’s Namaqualand in bloom in September 2008. Unlike Ruby, the floral presence in
Two’s collection did not echo a South African influence but rather an Eastern influence. Two’s collection had strong
Eastern references to floral prints – kimono style dresses and obi belts. In addition, floral embroidery and feminine
accessories such as brooches also characterised the sister’s collection. With regards to the fashion shows, I often found
myself asking the question “can I picture myself wearing that?” and for the Two collection I found myself saying yes a
number of times. Despite the lack of offering something completely new in terms of silhouette or style, I found the Two
collection to be quite favourable considering the positioning of the brand and the widespread accessibility of their clothing
in the South African market.
Considering that I was wearing very high heels, in between shows I was lucky enough to rest my feet in the VIP lounge.
These breaks proved to be almost as exciting as the SSAFW shows themselves as it was intriguing and even more
inspiring to see the attendees clad in a range of different and personal styles. Despite seeing photographers clicking
away at the shows, I think that South Africa should have its very own Scott Schuman (the photographer who has an
influential blog on style.com doing the rounds at such an event. A ‘street style’ blog on the Sanlam Fashion Week website
would be most welcome! Another personal highlight of the evening was getting to meet the South African-born, New
York-based Albertus Swanepoel, who is currently taking the fashion world by storm as the leading light in making hats
the en vogue accessory.
The last show for the evening was by Abigail Betz. In true Betz style, she presented a collection that epitomises beauty,
femininity and romance. Her collection of dresses, whether short or long, followed the same simple yet commanding
lines. A characteristic feature of her Spring/Summer 09 collection was the introduction of crochet, embroidery and
beading. In the Thought pattern brochure which was made available to the attending press, Abigail boldy states: “Screw
the Recession”. Although this statement made reference to the volume and choice of fabric and intricate details such as
the embroidery and beading, by not sharing the ramp with another designer, Abigail cements her attitude towards
screwing the recession. Perhaps this attitude is made possible by her new flagship store in Rosebank and her evergrowing
customer base.
The above mentioned shows were certainly a good articulation of contemporary South Africa fashion. I feel that South
African fashion is at a stage where it needs greater innovation to generate business opportunities both within South
Africa and globally, but nonetheless I have a feeling that SSAFW is headed in the right direction. In conclusion, the
experience which I had, will be sure to keep me going back for more. After all, isn’t ‘more’ the operative word of a ‘fashion
focused female’?
Day 2 of SSAFW brought its own highlights and challenges. Not only from the length of the shows but also the offering
from some of the designers. On the plus side was the breaks offered in the VIP room, where the previous collections
critique could be heard flying in every direction or being ‘loudly whispered’ in a friend’s ear – some good, some bad and
some so indifferent.
Tido by Tando Zamxaka does not indicated what his inspiration for this collection was in any of the press material
released. I wondered why? In his collection on display, there are elements that show a ‘street smartness’ in some
aspects, and yet some parts of the collection were just ‘unfortunate’ regarding embellishment. I do not know if this
collection made me want to sit up and take notice or just bury my head in the sand for the obvious mishaps. The
collection, or rather its lack of a central sense of concept or message, left me feeling ambiguous. It is unfortunate
because Thando Zamxaka has obvious talent but this collection lacked focus and maturity.
Sexy, sassy, sophisticated ensembles presented by Lebo Mash epitomised a sultry and seductive tailored temptress who
is young at heart. Her pleated and sometimes, loose fitting garments, were relaxed yet beautifully styled. The old was
given a breath of fresh air, as she took tried and tested silhouettes and applied them to great fabric choices – definitely
doing the female species naughty but nice attitude a world of good.
The idea of wearing your interior design draping accessories is quite novel in this economic downturn but most definitely
not something we should be advocating. It has to be said that costumes have their place and that is on a theatre stage.
When we talk everyday wear they are not exuberant nor do they imply confidence and energy. Yes, it is true they are
colourful, in a bad way. This collection did not work for me from a finished garment point of view (interior drapery finishes
appropriated for high fashion – wrong, wrong, wrong!) but for RjKay Creations I give u 100% for repurposing.
Diamond Face Couture’s inspiration is said to be captured by the words elegant, spring, satin, flowing, vivid florals and
bright colours, a tried and tested recipe. Dare I say that the result was bright and bold as the worst of 80’s ensembles ...
nothing new and nothing so old that you would not want to be seen dead in. I disliked this collection to the extent that I
would refrain from making further comments.
Tiaan Nagel, ... it did not work for me as the cuts were most unflattering or was it simply to thin models wearing the
outfits? A saving grace was the colour palate. On the whole, most definitely a no in my books for this one.
Superella by Ella Buter’s every day inspiration brought a breath of fresh air to the catwalk because of its
unpretentiousness. Almost 99.99% if not all present applauded this spirited lone voice of simplicity. The layering concept
was again evident and probably the only copy cat idea of the high-end stuff. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder
summarised this collection and to me it was beautifully simple and so damn wearable. I am sure every woman at the
showing recognised something from the dark recesses of their closets that was now back in fashion.
A much needed injection into the world of South African men’s fashion addressing necessary evils of style, fabric choice,
creativity, cut and wear-ability. Ephymol inspiration of ‘wear your luxury’ showcases the stylishness, creativity and pure
evidence of richness in men’s grooming. I for one will be wearing a number of their offerings.
Clive Rundle’s 09/10-summer collection was the epitome of style and elegance and surely the highlight of SSAFW. I do
not know so much about capturing his inspiration of ‘simple-mess’. The documentary themed runway show captured the
imagination and was certainly a lesson in presentation. The collection was immaculately constructed however questions
as to its wearability arise. The clothes were simply beautiful on a size zero model; I wonder how they would look on the
bigger boned women on the street. In essence South African Haute Couture with a creative use of fabric and layering
bordering on fashion art. I do not know what appealed to me more the presentation of the line or the fact that the day
was over.
Day three of Sanlam South African Fashion Week opened with the ELLE New Talent Runner-ups and Winner. Holistically
the collections were creative and showed great potential in the up and coming designers. They will definitely create a
much needed stir in the SA Fashion industry. Having said that, all the collections seemed to fall short in their cleverness.
The relationship between creativity and intelligent thought, in my opinion, is what transforms the average and good into
the great, exquisite and profound. But then we all have to start somewhere.
Layers of sheer, printed and colour fabrics with occasional straight lines and bold prints, this collection as described by
designer Marize Malan sought to create a playful ‘citrus rush’. Garments were well fitted and wearable fulfilling a variety
of tastes with styles that make use of straight, clean lines to others which experimented with flowing movement and
shapes. Pleats added detail and fit to the garments. Fabric choice at times seemed more edgy and streetwise than the
actual design of the clothes. Regardless, there is bound to be something in this collection that will catch your eye and
make its way into your closet.
The second collection by designer Khumo Moshimane, takes a retrospective look at her life being born and growing up in
the 80s. There is a distinct 80’s feel that comes across in the design, fabric choice and colour of the garments, but a
kaleidoscope of possibilities within this style is explored. In some outfits there is muted use of colour in which the cut and
design reflect the 80’s style. Other combinations show a bolder use of typically 80s ‘out of the tube colours’ and elements
such as ski pants but are offset with an asymmetrically cut jacket. The collection overall is wearable, bold, fun and
playful.
Tanya Demby presented a collection that was definitely out of the ordinary and maybe even a little out of place. Initial
thoughts wandered to a space meets 80s vibe that was hard to swallow. Yes it was experimental, even a bit creative but
seemed more suited for the theatre stage than the catwalk. According to Demby the inspiration for the collection came
from biblical references such as the breastplate worn by Israelite high priests. The simple design of the garments framed
translucent silhouettes placing most (if not all) the focus on the geometric, pop art (ish) jewellery worn by the models.
There was, in my opinion, little integration between the clothing and the jewellery. Beauty really does reside in the eye of
the beholder...I however, wouldn’t give this collection a second look.
The ELLE New Talent winner of 2008, Anisa Mapungwe, presented a collection that fused several styles showing a bold
and creative stance on fashion. Seeking to capture what she termed “the drive-thru generation” and “our world today”,
Mapungwe drew inspiration from pop art, massive consumption, the Transformers and Lily Allen. Interesting fabric
combinations and ‘commercial’ tribal prints were presented in bright colours and A-line silhouettes. In three words:
creative but un-flattering. The garments would indeed fit any woman but only because any woman would fit underneath
them.
A neutral palette with designs that captured a fun, light hearted take on dress was what defined Robyn De Klerk’s
collection. In her own words the designs combine structure with spontaneity, focusing on comfort and ready to wear
garments that take SA’s climactic elements into account. The organic shaped silhouettes are well thought out and are
enhanced by subtle, well-crafted detail. Overall a very versatile collection and very wearable but there may be room for a
bolder and more adventurous side to the designs.
Show 2 of the day featured the Mantsho, House of Olé and Guillotine collections.
Palesa Mokubung designing under her label, Mantsho, presented a collection that paraded African vintage with a
glamourous and luxurious edge to it. Her brand, Mantsho, means ‘brutally Black’ in Sesotho and her designs capture the
meaning of this in every way. The collection was uniquely South African but could be envisaged as being worn by any
woman from any part of the world. The shapes are bold, creative and create striking bell shaped silhouettes. In a brave
step, she took on the challenge of designing all the outfits using the same fabric and succeeded beautifully. Each
garment is unique and if anything, would only have women in a quandary unable to decide which to choose. The
inspiration for this collection according to Mokubung, came from music, space, spirituality, humanity, figures and love for
oneself. Wearing any of the designs would definitely give any woman a sense of confidence unmatched.
House of Olé, one of the many men’s collections showcased at SSAFW, combined metrosexual chic with an afro/eastern
influence. Combinations would be the operative word in this collection – and lots of it. Designer, Ole Ledimo, combined
fabrics, cuts and styles with distinct creative flair juxtaposing gloss and matte, old and new, African and eastern. Pieces
range from the more quirky, to the ready to wear, casual and comfortable. The collection shows a great deal of creative
experimentation and with all experimentation just sometimes not working in complete harmony. Combining old cuts/styles
with new trends created edgy menswear in some designs, but seemed hap-hazard in others. Overall we are undecided –
a collection that can go both ways depending on how you view it.
Urban with an English country vibe – if such a thing ever existed – is what portrays Lisa Jaffes’ collection of her label
Guillotine. The designs were stylish and sophisticated with a funky edge to them. She describes her inspiration as
searching for the grey area, the hidden and in between reflecting a mood that is elusive, border-less and difficult to
define. Greys in all shades, matte and gloss were tailored into garments that showed an eye for detail in carefully crafted
pleats and folding details. Hints of vibrant colours were subtly incorporated, providing a safe balance. The print motifs ere
emphasised as elements used to highlight individual and tribal identity mimicking fingerprint/signature shapes. Although
the collection as a whole may not seem particularly daring or novel, we felt that the allure of it lies in that the designs
serve to absorb and reflect the individual character of the wearer, enhancing it versus adding to it. You can be who you
are in these clothes al the while looking fabulous.
A neutral overdose. Colleen Eitzen describes her designs in this collection as the “simple solution” with a vision of highly
wearable, striking pieces in a neutral palette. And indeed, the pieces were flexible and versatile with a modern and
organic feel. Draped pieces were well constructed and created unique shapes and silhouettes in many of the designs.
Peaceful and tranquil and yet dreary in its representation of the corporate jungle.
Although this collection’s inspiration came from the naive and understated clothing of the Amish and traditional rural
Jewish communities and could be construed as ‘unexciting’ it is one that is not to be missed. Anna-Mari Pretorius
designing under the label, Soda, succeeded in extracting a pure adult innocence from these design styles and created
something beautifully intricate. The unique combination of styles lends itself to an urban chic that fuses seemingly
contradicting values. Crafting detail, such as embroidery, by crafters from KZN, is introduced onto the fabric providing a
natural touch and is offset with sophisticated lines in the cut. There is something to fall in love with in this collection.
Show 4 (4 April)
Contributor: Karuna Pillay
De Mil: The South African passion for being in the ourdoors was poorly equated to the ‘Howdy Cowboy’ look of this
collection. All I can say is Eish!, you far from home! The presentation and styling was too costumey and at times way to
haphazard for my liking.
Earthquake: Casual, bright, fun with an injection of colour into the otherwise drab men’s ware palette. A good
combination of street and smart wear. The only concern for me was the cut of some of the shorts’ pointy pockets which
were simply not flattering.
Narain Samy: This collection is a lesson in good tailoring and well-constructed and ageless garments. It seems like the
4th generation tailor were paying attention in their legacy lessons. Sophisticated with a distinct African flair reminiscing of
the hayday of Sophia Town comes to light. This is a very wearable collection by almost any man on the street who seeks
to be noticed.
Thunderstorm by Thabo: There really is not much to say about Thunderstorm’s collection. It was creative and quirky,
well-cut and neatly constructed but that about it. Nothing caught my attention or made me sit up and take note and that
goes for the bad stuff in the collection as well.
Show 5 (4 April)
Contributor: Anri Theron
Story’s collection, created by designer Sanche Frolich, presented designs that were versatile, wearable, creating a multilayered
yet simple look in silhouettes. Frolich describes the collection as conveying a modern mix of feminine boldness,
“taking a dance journey into luxury with tribal inspired minimalist, clustered embellishments and intricate fringing and
ruffles.” However in my opinion this journey made a few wrong turns in a few too many places. To begin with, what’s
new? Yes many of the designs were appealing and flattering but not because they were novel, creative or exciting in any
way but because its been done, tested and proven to work. The simplicity and everyday wearability was overshadowed
by the heavy-set accessories. Unbalance works but needs to be carefully paired with intelligent thought. Having said that
there are a few individual pieces that stand out and worth a second look. Many of the designs centred around the
sophistication portrayed by the little black dress. Overall a very wearable and versatile collection but it lacks a much
needed burst of creativity.
Stoned Cherrie closed SSAFW with a collection that in my personal opinion did not do the brand justice. Maybe it was
the fact that they recently showed at the New York Fashion week in February or that this collection was specifically
designed for a retail market. Whatever the reason may be, the collection seemed a diluted version of what the Stoned
Cherrie brand epitomises. The pieces were bright, bold, fun with an air of sexy sophistication. Options for day to evening,
casual to a bit more formal were all presented with a uniquely South African spin to them. A few individual pieces really
captured the imagination with multiple layers of fabric and sensual lines. Stoned Cherrie described this summer 09/10
collection as artfully and sexily swerving fashion stereotypes and daring to be different. Everyone stumbles– the key is to
do so gracefully, and this they did do. The fact remains that Stoned Cherrie is Stoned Cherrie – their brand, clothes and
distinctive African design aesthetic with its celebration of South Africa’s rich heritage and icons will remain a force to be
reckoned with. Appreciation for them and their popularity are cemented in their lovingly nonconformist revolutionary
expression of freedom which, I think, is something everyone can identify with.
Works of urban art by top local artists on auction to raise funds for Write on Africa to give Cape Town communities a ‘face lift’. Bid now on rare works of art and change the face of Cape Town communities...
On Saturday, 4 April, Write on Africa, in association with Artjamming and Word of Art, presented a very different art event.
Rare works of art were created by some of the biggest names in urban art at the Artjamming studio which is being
auctioned off to raise money for the Write on Africa Mural Fund to ‘change the face’ of underprivileged communities.
“Through projects like these we hope to enlighten and educate the public on the value and positives of this art form. The
idea is to uplift youth and entire communities through creative inspiration and bring about massive social change through
art,” says Ricky Lee Gordon, director of Write on Africa.
Seven original works by six top local artists (of whom some are internationally known); Rasty, Faith47, Mak1one, Senyol
and Love and Hate (a team of two artists; 351073 and Black Koki), are currently on auction through 34 Long Fine Art and
Onauction. A web site (www.writeonafrica.com) has been created for bidding and to expose the project to a bigger
audience. The web site also features a catalogue of these and other pieces by the same artists, for auction. The gallery
section shows how Write on Africa puts this money to use; documenting their travels and paintings in townships. The
artworks are currently on exhibit at Artjamming at the trendy lifestyle centre, Wembley Square in the heart of Cape Town,
where art enthusiasts can view and bid on owning one of these incredible art pieces. “Artjamming is proud to be
associated with such a worthy cause and we like to get involved with projects which are different and innovative,” says
Leora Israel, co-owner of Artjamming.
Worldwide, urban art has been embraced as a very popular and contemporary promotional medium and it has become a
much sought after and recognised fine art form. Similar initiatives as this one have also taken place in London, Australia,
New York and Brazil. Local companies that have worked with Word of Art and have seen the value of using this medium,
include Adidas, Red Bull, Nike, Nedbank, Sappi, SABC1 and the National Blood Bank.
To celebrate the first day of the school holidays, Artjamming also provided 30 smaller canvasses for kids and parents to
create their own works of art and release the budding artists inside.
Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week in Qatar was a multi-disciplinary, week-long series of events, co-hosted by the International Council of Graphic Design Associations (Icograda) and Virginia Commenwealth University Qatar (VCU Qatar), serving the global design community...
Mousharaka brought together practitioners, scholars, and students from across design disciplines, cultures and regions
to build bridges, raise awareness of the importance and promise of collaboration, and create bonds necessary to achieve
the full potential of design in the Gulf region and beyond.
Donna Duffet
Events Coordinator, VCU Qatar
Icograda Design Week
PO Box 8095
Doha, Qatar t. +974 492 7245 f. +974 481 7058 e. dduffett@qatar.vcu.edu w. www.mousharaka.com
The theme of the Design Week was Mousharaka, meaning ‘collaboration’. “Collaboration is a combined effort resulting in
the deepening of inter-relationships and shared knowledge. Design is now considered a team endeavor where
collaboration is crucial to achieve innovative results that are inclusive of cultures and mediums. Designers are crossing
boundaries and have become part of creative interdisciplinary teams that address broader issues of communication,
style, space, systems thinking, cultural identity and commerce. Through collaboration with others, designers have
become instrumental in teams that affect change on a global level”, said Muneera Umedaly Spence, the chair of the
organising committee.
The Design Week attracted participation from most parts of the world and the following reportage, facilitated by
VCUQatar, Icograda and DESIGN> magazine, provides an overview of the procedures, presentations and photographic
documentation of the events. In addition, the reportage also includes links to speakers’ websites and project pages.
Education Symposium > 28 February 2009
Contributors: Priya D'Souza (VCUQatar) and Jacques Lange (DESIGN> magazine)
[white text]
The Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week programme kicked off with the Education Symposium on a typically hot Dohan
Saturday at the campus of VCUQatar, Education City. The diversity of dress of those who attended the opening
ceremony clearly reflected the multi-cultural and broad demographic representation of the audience – young and old,
students, academics and professional designers, government officials and the press, clad in abayas, jilbabs, tubes, saris,
punjabis, jeans and sneakers, business suits, and the like. This diversity set the tone and sparked the lively energy for
what was to follow during the next six days – a convergence of cultures, generations and tought leadeship.
In her welcome address, host Allyson Vanstone, Dean of VCUQatar, said: “Mousharaka is one moment in the ongoing,
educational and professional project that we each work towards in our everyday practice. We look forward to continuing
the communication and building upon the initiatives, connections and ideas being explored this week.”
Don Ryun Chang, Icograda President from South Korea, extended his congratulations and appreciation to the VCUQatar
for their partnership in presenting Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week in Qatar. “The core spirit of Icograda has always
been a collaborative culture among our members that enables us to create a shared vision and common values.
Collaboration is a combined effort resulting in the deepening of relationships and shared knowledge,” he added. He
concluded by expressing shared hopes that the Design Week – the first collaboration of its kind in the Middle East –
would take designers on the road to further innovation.
First on stage was Brockett Horne, co-chair of graphic design at the Maryland Institute College of Art in Baltimore, USA,
who spoke about changes in the role of the designer in practice and the opportunities that it provides for incorporating
entrepreneurial skills into design curricula. Horne focused on the emergence of ‘clientless practice’ whereby designers
deliver self-initiated ‘products’ as opposed to just delivering professional services to clients. She talked about how
designers are crafting new solutions for savvy audiences and setting opportunities to work in new collaborative ways.
She showed examples of student projects, which she facilitated and elaborated on how designers can work as activists,
researchers, artists and enablers by initiating projects rather than just executing them. Read more about Brockett Horne
Kelly Beaverford, the second presenter, has worked on design and education projects in Uganda, Sri Lanka, Nepal,
Cambodia, Iran, Qatar, Turkey and Canada. Now teaching at the Faculty of Architecture at the University of Manitoba,
she focuses on cross-cultural design and studio pedagogy. Beaverford is also the founder and Executive Director of
Architects Without Borders Canada. She co-presented with Leland Hill, Assistant Professor of Graphic Design at
VCUQatar, focussing on the topic of ‘service learning’ in the global community. Beaverford and Hill first presented a case
study titled: The Little Tea House that Grew, which was executed in the rural village of Deydinler, Turkey. The project
entailed building a tea house for the community, taking an exhisitng architectural structure and converting it into a tea
house that would serve the majority of the local village community. Architecture, interior design, landscape planning and
communication design students from the two universities first got to know each other, and then worked together with the
community to make this project possible.
Beaverford and Hill also presented a library building project which they initiated in Uganda. This project highlighted the
complexities of working in countries with challenging, socio-economic, cultural, political and developmental contexts, and
indicated the challenges entailed in developing culturally-sensitive areas in design education curricula aimed at teaching
inter-cultural competencies.
Ian Grout, the third presenter of the day, has been researching and teaching in product design at the Glasgow School of
Art where he is specifically concerned with future developments in ecological and sustainable design. His presentation,
Wide Horizons, focused on designing design education and its aspects as a collaborative activity: across disciplines,
across cultures and how these collaborative perspectives afforded more meaningful practices.
The last speaker of day one, Claudia Meyer-Newman, is Educational Director at AIGA, USA. Meyer-Newman’s role
entails supporting students in the AIGA Student Chapter at Cornish College of the Arts. Her presentation, Collaborative
Learning Communities: 360 ways of creating relevance, focused on designers’ roles as strategic design thinkers who can
contribute to advancing knowledge and enhancing both local and global understanding.
The first day’s procedures concluded with four hours of student workshops, which provided students the opportunity to
collaborate in an energetic atmosphere lead by the Education Symposium presenters and VCU and VCUQatar faculty.
The workshop themes were: Getting started; Co.Lab; First contact: How to start collaboration; Mousharaka: The
typeface; Extreme design thinking; Playsphere: Where play meets collaboration; Making Doha: Mapping the
contemporary Gulf city; Mapping the meaning of place; and Collaborative digital storytelling with a shared narrative.
Images by Marcus Elblaus
From Top to Bottom:
A section of the audience attending the Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week, Doha.
Delegates during a break, reflecting the diversity of cultures assembled at the Mousharaka event
VCUQatar Dean, Allyson Vanstone, delivering the welcome address at the Education Symposium
Icograda President, Don Ryun Chang, delivering the welcome address at the opening of the Education Symposium
Education Symposium speakers, Leland Hill, Brocket Horne, Kelley Beaverford, Ian Grout and Claudia Meyer-Newman.
Contributors: Priya D'Souza (VCUQatar) and Jacques Lange (DESIGN> magazine)
Day two of the Education Symposium brought five more speakers to the stage from various disciplines and from as far
afield as New Zealand, UAE, USA, and India.
First up was Nicholas Vanderschantz, who lecturers at the Computer Science Department at the University of Waikato, in
Hamilton, New Zealand. His presentation dealt with ‘Digital Storytelling’ as an art form. Communication design students
at the University of Waikato worked on a collaborative project with institutional partners spanning a 4-year period, to
create and develop a series of digital stories. These stories were many and varied in their themes and communication
aesthetics and included live motion, stop motion, animation, photography, typography, hand rendered and computer
rendered illustrations. According to Vanderschantz, the students learnt about communicating in collaboration, developing
trust through honesty and became aware of the need for transparency of process.
The second speaker, Farid Esmaeil, is the founding partner of x-architects, a leading architecture and urban design
practice in Dubai. Esmaeil has been a driving force in conceptual projects such as Xeritown, a 60 hectare sustainable
city in Dubai, and Al Nasseem, a 12 hectare community development in Al-Ain, amongst others. His presentation on
Xeritown dealt with sustainable urbanisation through collaboration focusing on the vision of the project, the ideas
exchanged, methods of collaboration, the teams involved and the design. As the team comprised of various professions
involved in building this town – from engineers, communication designers to landscape and lighting designers – based in
London, Berlin, Cape Town, Zurich, Dubai, Iran and San Francisco, the primary mode of communication was a ‘digital
online sketchbook’ which would involve everyone contributing proposals and comments. This would then go for approval
to clients and changes would be made accordingly – a successful example of how this collaboration worked with the
online sketchbook. Read more about Farid Esmaeil and x-architects
Barbara Sudick is the Nierenberg Distinguished Professor of Design in the School of Design at Carnegie Mellon
University where she teaches collaborative interdisciplinary classes to graduate and post-graduate students in
Communication Planning and Information Design and Human Computer Interaction. Frank Armstrong is a visiting
Assistant Professor in the School of Design at Carnegie Mellon, teaching graduate and undergraduate courses in
Typography, Interaction and Motion Design. Their presentation focussed on using collaboration plus indigenous
knowledge to teach sustainable design. The presentation emphasised several critical factors: 350 million indigenous
people from over 70 countries, comprising 5 000 languages and cultures, live sustainably. The presentation highlighted
that these people are a tremendous knowledge resource since ther ‘collaboration’ with the ecosystem has been longterm
and holistic. Sudick and Armstrong argued that the design community today can learn much from the indigenous
people, especially the manner in which they collaborate as communities and apply their indigenous practices. Sudick and
Armstrong believe that the application of these practices are the only way for humanity and the earth to sustain itself.
The final speaker of the day was Dr. Ajanta Sen, the International Director of Solar Project, a networking technology
experimentation with cross-cultural collaborative learning environments for children. Her presentation entitled ‘Mela
(India) meets Mousharaka (Qatar)’ focused on inspirations from culturally rooted practices and constructs to drive crosscultural
collaboration in design. She highlighted the custom of ‘Potlatch’ practiced by the kwakwakwa’kwakw Indian tribe
of British Columbia, which entailes a gift giving ceremony that serves a host of functions, essential to keeping the spirit
alive in difficult times, as in the case of the economy today, while promoting altruism in the community.
Sen also presented Khotachiwadi, a village inside a city, which dealt with providing support through technology and the
Solar Project – which networked a cross-cultural environment mediated through technology. The Khotachiwadi project
brief given to students entailed that they capture the culturally rich information offered by the village community and
locating ‘design opportunities’ while retaining earlier acts of collaboration.
The presentations were followed by a vibrant Q&A session between the speakers and the audience. The day’s
proceedings again concluded with students and speakers collaborating in four hours of student workshops, continuing to
develop the work that they had done on day one.
Images by Marcus Elblaus
From Top to Bottom:
Nicholas Vanderschantz
Farid Esmaeil
Frank Armstrong and Barbara Sudick
Dr. Ajanta Sen
Education Symposium, MEDEA meeting and the opening of the Professional Conference > 2 March 2009
Contributors: Priya D'Souza (VCUQatar) and Jacques Lange (DESIGN> magazine)
The Education Symposium concluded on the morning of the third day of Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week, Doha. The
students’ two-day workshops culminated in an exhibition of the best work and presentations focusing on nine topics. The
workshop facilitators presented a gist of the workshops with their groups of 20 students each.
Brockett Horne’s project ‘Mousharaka: the typeface’ had participants work together to create a pictorial font that
expressed their collective ideas about Qatar. Students created a font covering everything from camel paw prints, local
architecture, Arabic calligraphy, seascapes, mosques, the Qatari flag, traffic, buildings, sandstorms, Gahwa, the oryx,
pearl, sun and the majlis. This font was then digitized, giving students the overall experience of engaging in cross-cultural
expression while using design to mediate interaction for those that use the font.
Barbara Sudick and Frank Armstrong’s project ‘Mapping the meaning of places’ focused on sensitising people to value
the environment and think about sustainability, and experiencing places through their senses to show that they cared for
the place. Sudick and Armstrong asked the students to abandon their previously planned trip to the traditional Qatari
Souq Waqif, and instead visit the Villaggio, a newly-built Venetian-styled shopping mall, as inspiration for their project.
There they spread out and soaked in through sight and sound the different senses and colors, met with people from
different cultures and shared points of view that they never had given a thought to before, and incorporated all of this into
their project.
Claudia Meyer-Newman’s ‘Extreme Design Thinking’ workshop produced a campaign that addressed the world’s water
crisis. The project started with students watching Irena Salina’s award-winning documentary ‘Flow’ and then
brainstormed, visualised ideas and reframed what seemed like an ‘unsolvable’ problem to create feasible solutions
dealing with key issues like contamination, water shortage, privatisation and depravation of clean water. They designed
an interactive installation with questions in bottle caps for guests attending Mousharaka whose responses were
documented as used in developing proposed solutions.
Leland Hill and Kelly Beaverford’s ‘Getting Started’ workshop contributed to the development of a course called ‘Service
Learning in the Global Community’. A series of exercises were conducted and four topics were selected as final
animations. These included religious discrimination: a video featuring portraits that focused on the similarities as
opposed to the differences. Other animations focused on the themes of the Environment, War & Peace and Education.
Farid Esmaeil’s ‘Co.Lab.’ workshop had students work with a postcard, bringing to it all of their ideas and techniques
from their different fields – graphic, interior and fashion design – to put together a display of disparate images, texts,
diagrams coalesced into a fluid sequence of thoughts on the theme of collaboration. The outcome was a set of postcards
that became a souvenir for the Mousharaka events.
Ajanta Sen’s ‘Playspheres’ workshop aimed to explore ‘play’ as a world of its own, where play comes in the guise of
various activities not always obvious as play but with the promise of play. Students were encouraged to think out of the
box and visualise environments and strategies aimed at heightening the values of our daily lives through a combination
of play and collaboration resulting in a conceptual world residing in a series of mental maps, which could very well exist
in the real world.
Nic Vanderschantz’s ‘Collaborative Digital Storytelling’ workshop explored the potential of digital storytelling to create
collaborative and shared digital narratives. The students talked, moved around, brainstormed, learnt to be good listeners
and time-managers and produced animations that featured all of these experiences.
Reda Sejini’s ‘Made in Doha: Mapping the Contemporary Gulf City’ workshop required students to document a sector or
zone of the City of Doha, using a digital camera and sketches. They then presented their findings for discussion and after
a ‘filtering process’, the examples that most represented the city’s innate culture, was used to produce a booklet which
could act as a cultural guide to the city, accompanied by a brief essay on why these aspects of Doha’s DNA make it
‘Doha’.
Ian Grout’s ‘First Contact’ workshop gathered experiences from students focusing of their similarities rather than their
differences. These were then used to creative different kinds of narratives using images to form collages, as interactive
web pages, mailers, and interactive business cards based on themes of self, family and home.
The Education Symposium ended with a summary by Rick Poynor, the highly respected British writer on design, media
and visual culture and Founding Editor of Eye magazine, who was tasked to extract core information from the
Symposium presentations and Student Workshops, bridging, interconnecting and reframing the presented ideas while
also summarising the knowledge gained. Poyner was further asked to consolidate and present his personal findings and
views. While agreeing to the many positive aspects of collaboration presented at the Education Symposium and Student
Workshops, he hoped designers would also come up with other realistic solutions that addressed more issues. In true
Poynorial-style, he asked: “Why did everyone opt to agree? Why didn’t anyone risk disagreeing with the posed
opinions?” Poynor concluded: “It’s all good and well to talk about collaboration in this forum, but how does it convert to
real life?”
The afternoon of day three was dedicated to a Gulf regional education meeting. The objective of this meeting was to
officially form and launch the Middle East Design Education Association (MEDEA). The intent of MEDEA is to bring
educators from the Middle East together in a formal structure to build a working regional and international network, which
will focus on excellence in teaching and research as well as preparing students to strive for excellence in design. This
meeting was seminal in that it brought together stakeholders from many parts of the Gulf region to formalise
collaboration through an official body. This is a new concept in this region since the Gulf, and its individual countries, do
not have any formalised professional bodies looking after the development and interests of design and designers.
MEDEA aims to be a platform for educators charged with getting the most out of design. Sonia Ashour, design
entrepreneur from Saudi Arabia, Australian Russell Kennedy, President Elect Icograda and British designer Ian
Silverstein were the speakers who focused on designers of the future and integration of design opportunities into
business, civil society, design entrepreneurship and design leadership. VCUQatar’s Assistant Professor Peter Martin was
assigned as facilitator generating a vision statement and agenda for future MEDEA meetings.
The highlight of the third day of Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week, Doha was the official opening of the Professional
Conference. Muneera Umedaly Spence, Chairperson of the Mousharaka Organising Committee presided over the
formalities. This was followed by VCUQatar Dean, Allyson Vanstone’s, welcome speech.
Vanstone thanked the Minister of Labor, Dr Sultan Al Dosari, Icograda President Don Chang, Vice-President of Education
for the Qatar Foundation Dr Abdullah Al Thani and the audience, welcoming them to the Professional Conference of
Mousharaka, the first Icograda Design Week ever to be hosted in the Arabian Gulf. She went on to thank the VCUQatar
faculty and the Icograda board members for making this conference a reality.
Ms Vansotne continued by expressing her hopes for outcomes in the coming three days during the Mousharaka
Professional Conference: “I am hoping for inspiration and the development of a dialogue that will energise design
thinking in all spheres of design activity.” She continued by highlighting VCUQatar’s tenth anniversary and what the
university has achieved and presented plans that the institution aims to accomplish in the near future: “Our primary
mission is to lead design education in Qatar, and build regional capacity for a design research culture and a thriving,
innovative, design profession. The scope of this challenge can only be accomplished through ongoing cooperation
across cultures, religions, languages, disciplines, industries and countries. The attendance tonight of over 400 people in
this audience, including 168 students from 14 different countries, ranging from Australia to Zimbabwe, tells me that we
have lots of partners who are willing to join us in this endeavor. As the speakers and participants at the Mousharaka
Edication Symposium so clearly illustrated during the past three days, design in the 21st century is an interdisciplinary,
international and collaborative venture,” she added.
She concluded by thanking Her Highness, Sheikha Mozah bint Nasser Al Missned, Chairperson of the Qatar Foundation
for her vision and inexhaustible commitment to education and wished everyone an engaging conference.
Don Chang, Icograda President addressed the gathering next, thanking Qatar Foundation and VCUQatar for hosting this
Design Week in partnership with Icograda. He spoke about the relevance of design in the world today and how the role
of designers had evolved so they were now communication designers, evolving responsibly in a changing planet,
creating through interdisciplinary channels, thoughts of social, economical and cultural benefits for society.
Dr Abdullah Al Thani addressed the gathering on behalf of Qatar Foundation and spoke of His Highness, the Emir of
Qatar’s vision to equip the country and the region to meet the challenges of the 21st century and how the Qatar
Foundation positioned itself to facilitate this by focusing on the three pillars of education, research and community
development. “The first to come was Virginia Commonwealth University’s School of the Arts. And I can say that, during
the 10 years it has been here, it has made major contributions to all three parts of our mission,” he said. “But the hosting
of this international design conference is for us a coming of age, and just as the opening of the Museum of Islamic Art
has marked Doha’s accession to the title of one of the world’s great cultural capitals, hosting the Icograda Design Week
in Doha does something similar in the area of design,” he remarked. He concluded by stating his hopes that guests
leaving Qatar would be enriched by having witnessed, for a very short time, the remarkable developments that are
transpiring in Qatar.
The highlight of the evening was the notable keynote address by renowned Qatari architect, Ibrahim Jaidah, who
elaborated on the importance of ‘Mousharaka’, as a design philosophy, and how without it, we could not have been able
to develop the civilisation we have today. Amongst others, he presented examples of the influence that Venetian artists
and designers have had on Middle Eastern architecture, how the Ottomans, when they went to Europe, invited artists
from all over the world to create masterpieces – another form of Mousharaka.
Jaidah’s also presented examples of his most notable professional work, such as the work that he had done on the
Sharq Village & Spa. He spoke about how his design team had to recreate the 1960s neighborhood that existed on the
original site but had since been demolished. He talked about working with the client, Qatar National Hotels, to make this
feasible and the Thai spa operator, who had to learn about the regional culture and everything it entailed from the
segregation of sexes to the effect of shades and shadows – resulting in a beautiful traditional-looking spa and resort
complex.
“Everything from the lobby to the bedrooms had a theme. The lobby had to be spacious, yet contemporary, the bedrooms
straight out of the Arabian Nights – all local vernacular. Yet we had to make this work, as the hotel has to make money, of
course,” he smiled. He mentioned the other key service providers involved in the project, from the designers, and
landscape artists to the management Ritz Carlton. He spoke of how the success of this collaboration resonated every
time one walked through the hotel.
He continued by highlighting some of his other projects such as the 100-storey building that he consulted with worldfamous
architects on, and the very contemporary mosque, where he worked very closely with celebrated Japanese
architect Arata Isozaki. He concluded by telling the students in the audience about how fortunate they were to have the
opportunities given to them and how they could be leading designers in the region.
Jaidah is a pioneer of a new movement in architecture in the Gulf who combines the far-reaching influences of Islamic art
with a modern style. AEB’s work has led to several awards, including two other Arab Cities Awards and one Islamic Cities
Award. Jaidah will soon be publishing a book charting the history of Qatari Architecture, followed by a second book
chronicling the evolution of the AEB architectural style. Read more about Ibrahim Jaidah (www.aljaidah-brothers.com)
and AEB’s activities (www.aeb-qatar.com)
Images by Marcus Elblaus
From Top to Bottom:
Barabara Sudick and Franks Armstrong with their workshop group
Farid Esmaeil working with his workshop participants on the theme: Co.Lab
British design critic, Rick Poyner, delivering his conclusions at the end of the Education Symposium
The MEDEA speakers, Russell Kennedy, Sonia Ashour, Ian Silverstein and Peter Martin
Indian designer, Ajanta Sen, engaging with her workshop participants
Contributors: Priya D'Souza (VCUQatar) and Jacques Lange (DESIGN> magazine)
Day four of Mousharaka opened on 3 March 2009, with Muneera Umedaly Spence’s, chairperson of the organising
committee introducing the first speaker of the Professional Conference, Mario Gagliardi.
Gagliardi is the CEO of the Design Zone, Qatar, a new initiative of the Qatar Foundation, and a visionary development
project for the first global creative hub in the Arabian Gulf. Gagliardi crafted the strategy for the Design Zone while
leading ‘mg strategy’, a think-tank for design. His keynote address entitled ‘Designing the Future’ addressed how the
geography of economics is rapidly changing the design world and how people’s expectations are becoming more
demanding. He elaborated on how one-sided approaches were unable to tackle these complex issues of the 21st
century and he highlighted the need for a ‘fresh start’.
He continued to present the resonspes developed by the Qatari Design Zone, which aims to be a place that focusses on
inspiring creative professionals, establishing a platform to learn from the best, and a becoming a catalyst for design
thinking and innovation. Design Zone in Doha is envisioned to build and develop a creative community, a livable
community, involving everything from theater, to open air cinemas, beaches and vegetable gardens. It will be based on
traditional Qatari architecture, which is eco-friendly, as opposed to modern architecture, which produces 66 tons of
carbon emissions per sq. km. per year.
According to Gagliardi, Design Zone will be a “life-work creative resort, a zero-carbon community with life-work balance.
So designers can go fishing while they’re grappling with ideas, thereby living and working in an environment that enables
creativity. Design Zone is the first major project in the Gulf dedicated entirely to creativity and design, and as such, a
major impetus for the future.” Read more about the Design Zone Qatar. Read more about
Mario Gagliardi
Petra Blaisse, was the second speaker to address the Professional Conference. Blaisse, a leading theatre curtain and
landscape designer, introduced her presentation by providing background information on her company, Inside Outside.
She explained how her company operates and how the studio developed from a one-woman unit into a professional
studio, and continued to explain the company’s collaborations with leading international architects. Blaisse talked about
the domains in which Inside Outside works – interiors and exteriors. Starting with the emancipation of the curtain,
followed by the philosophy, the garden, and the interior, and vice versa.
Blaisse’s poetically presented paper showcased examples of her work, some of which included the restoration project for
the Hackney Empire Theatre in London (all curtains) and acoustic walls and curtains for the Mercedes Benz museum in
Stuttgart, and many others. Blaisse’s presentation was surely a highlight of the Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week. Her
elequent presentation was humble and honest and the quality of work that she presented left the audience feeling dumb
stuck with the beauty that Inside Outside managed to create around the world. Read more about Petra Blaisse and
Inside Outside
The next speaker was Dr Sami Angawi, a former fellow of the Graduate School of Design at Harvard University. Angawi
has a Doctorate of Philosophy in Islamic Architecture from the University of London, and a Master of Arts in Architecture
from the University of Texas in Austin. He is the Founder and General Director of the AMAR Center in Jeddah, Saudi
Arabia. The AMAR Center restores and rehabilitates traditional buildings and houses in Jeddah, Makkah
Almumukaramah and Almadinah Almunawarah. Angawi, in his presentation took the audience on a journey from his days
as a student in Austin until the present. His presentation titled ‘Al Mizan’ (the balance), focused on achieving a state of
equilibrium by taking into account all factors, the evolving versus the constant; change versus continuity; and diversity
versus unity. He showed examples of architecture projects from Mecca (his city) and his personal residence, the Al-
Makkiyah residential villa, which epitomises the concept, methodology and visual expression of all these factors. Another
example he elaborated on was the Boston Islamic Cultural Center. Angawi’s interactive presentation left the audience
completely inspired. Read more about Dr Sami Angawi. The final professional presenter of the morning session, David Gibson, is an internationally recognised and published
pioneer in the field of public information design. As the co-founder and managing principal of Two Twelve Associates, Inc.
in New York City, Gibson has always believed in the power of design to transform public spaces and people’s awareness
of their urban environments. His presentation focussed on how wayfinding design is an inherently collaborative practice –
it is about people and places and helping people understand places that may not be familiar to them. He talked about the
four ways to present such information: connectors, districts, landmarks, streets. Gibson presented several case studies
and also described different models for successful inter-disciplinary collaboration. Read more about David Gibson and
Two Twelve Associates, Inc.
The afternoon session commenced with a presentation by Kittiratana Pitipanich, an architect, educator and entrepreneur,
who is currently the Design Advisory Director for the Thailand Creative & Design Center (TCDC), a nationally funded
public organisation created to serve as an education and resource center for the study and advancement of design. His
presentation focused on how TCDC, in cooperation with private sectors, SME entrepreneurs and designers, aims to raise
public awareness in using design to add value to their products, along with helping Thai designers’ work gain visibility in
the local and global marketplace. He elaborated on TCDC’s mission, vision and the creative economy, giving an
overview of Thailand’s creative industries and concluding with the roadmap of Thailand’s creative economy. Read more about the Thailand Creative & Design Center
The second speaker of the afternoon, Nada Debs, has been lauded at furniture design shows in Paris and London and
has built up a faithful clientele spanning several continents. Her iconic floating stools can be found in almost every chic
Beiruti home, and have even been the subject of contemporary artists’ work. Through her personal experience, designing
furniture has taken on many forms of collaboration: a collaboration between cultural identities – mainly between the
minimalism of the Japanese aesthetic and the elaborate aspect of Middle Eastern design; a collaboration between
different times – between the past and the present – the traditional and the modern; a collaboration between two different
worlds – that of the craftsmen and that of the industrialist; a collaboration between the heart and the mind – reclaiming
the role of emotion alongside logic. Her presentation emphasised her belief that design is the perfect medium through
which one can study the essence of these conflicts and contradictions and resolve them harmoniously. Her East & East
furniture line has emanated from the conflicting nature of these elements. Read more about Nada Debs
The last speaker of the day was Nigerian author, Chris Abani. He has been described as a writer with mesmerising
power, embracing warmth and transcendent compassion. He is a Professor at the University of California, Riverside and
the recipient of many awards. His prose includes Song For Night, The Virgin of Flames, Becoming Abigail, GraceLand,
and Masters of the Board. His poetry collections are Hands Washing Water, Dog Woman, Daphne's Lot, and Kalakuta
Republic. His luminous presentation highlighted the redemptive power of art to battle tyranny and to remind us of our
common humanity. Read more about Chris Abani
Design Debate Doha
The proceedings of the fourth day of Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week, Doha concluded on a high note with the much
anticipated Design Debate Doha, which was conceptualised by Icograda Vice President, Halim Choueiry, who thought
that Mousharaka would be a perfect platform to launch a debate of this kind. The format was based on the model of the
BBC Doha Debates and attracted a packed venue. Design Debate Doha focused on the topic ‘This house believes:
Globalization harmfully subverts culturally unique sensibilities.’ Panelists for the motion included writer and design critic
from the UK, Rick Poynor, Dr Sami Angawi, Founder and General Director of the AMAR Center in Saudi Arabia, and
Australian educator and designer, Russell Kennedy. Panelists against the motion included Qatari architect Ibrahim
Jaidah, Roger Mandle, Head of the Qatar Museums Authority and Petra Blaisse, founder of design studio Inside Outside.
Both sides put forward very strong arguments for their case and the audience asked questions which were just as
passionate. Kamahl Santamaria, the enigmatic Al Jazeera English channel presenter moderated the discussion.
Speaking for the motion Poynor spoke about globalisation being responsible for most cities in the world looking the same
with commercial icons such as McDonald’s being present everywhere. He compared this to forms of colonialism and
imperialism, and said that heritage sites were overtaken by ‘tacky’ commercialism. Poyner claimed that: “We can lay the
blame at the door of a certain political attitude which supports extreme commercialisation.” Jaidah, speaking against the
motion, talked about how globalisation helped small countries like Qatar learn from other cultures and implement better
practices. He gave the example of the Fulla doll, developed as an Arab alternative to Barbie. Fulla provides Arab children
with their own cultural icon instead of emulating Barbie.
Speaking for the motion, Kennedy continued in the same vein as Poynor, and talked about how Americanism was taking
over the world and how indigenous cultures were being lost to Coca-Cola and Disney. He contextualised his argument by
looking at the influence of globalization in four areas: Language (the loss of indigenous languages); Storytelling (who’s
stories are we telling); Main street (homogenisation of urban landscapes) and concluded with Defining beauty. The latter
looked at the alarming rise of cosmetic surgery and cosmetics in Asia and Africa to alter ethnic features in favour of the
Western aesthetic.
Blaisse started her argument against the motion by showing the famous 17th century painting, The Music Lesson, by Jan
Vermeer. She said that the famous masterpiece was a good illustration of the positive aspects of globalisation. She
analised the geographic origins of all the elements portrayed in the paining and claimed that the global exploration of the
world led to the Golden Age of The Netherlands. She also stood her ground by using nature as an example, using
ecological studies in the USA as a departure point. When botanists were looking at how local plants were facing
extinction, they thought it was because of the foreign invader plants. So, they worked to eliminate the foreign invaders
only to find that this exacerbated the situation. This proved, she said, that even nature agreed that foreign elements were
necessary for local ones to thrive.
The last speaker for the motion, Dr Angawi, said while he wasn’t against globalisation, he couldn’t accept the concept of
superimposition that globalisation came with. He talked about the superimposition of the new on the old, in the bargain
destroying heritage sites and anything of the old that should have been treasured. He used his hometown of Mecca to
illustrate his point. The final speaker, Mandle referred to globalisation as globalism instead, and talked about how cultural
exchange existed from the times of the crusaders and Ottomans. He argued that not just the West, but even the East,
and countries like Qatar were able to export technologies and processes because of globalism today. He compared the
fear of globalism to Talebanism and the North Korean way – closed cultures who were fanatic in a bid to keep other
cultures from polluting their own. He said nobody would thrive in this kind of cultural isolation.
The debate allowed questions from the floor and concluded with the audience voting on an audited electronic system. In
the end the audience voted 47% for the motion and 53% against.
Images by Marcus Elblaus
From Top to Bottom:
Panelists for the motion were Rick Poynor, Russell Kennedy and Dr Sami Angawi.
Dr Sami Angawi presenting his arguments at the Design Debate Doha. Seated are the panel against the motion, Ibrahim
Jaidah, Petra Blaisse and Roger Mandle
David Gibson
Dr Sami Angawi
Nada Debs speaking at the Professional Conference
Day five of Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week, Qatar started with another keynote speaker, Mark Kingwell. He is a
Professor of Philosophy at the University of Toronto and a contributing editor of Harper’s Magazine. He is the author of
eleven books of political and cultural theory, including the bestsellers Better Living (1998) and The World We Want
(2000). His articles on art, architecture and design have appeared in, among others, Harper’s, the Harvard Design
Magazine, the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, to name just a few.
Kingwell's presentation was titled: ‘Concrete Reveries: Consciousness and the City’, which is also the title of his latest
book. He discussed the relationship between consciousness and built forms. He pointed that Descartes’ notion of
consciousness suggests a complete separation between mind and body is not very satisfying to the embodied
consciousness which we experience. He purposed to answer three questions by looking at three cities and linking them
to quotations by famous philosophers:
"The mere object is not the work of art." – Martin Heidegger
"When is art?" – Nelson Goodman
"The city is time lived as space." – Henri Lefebvre
Kingwell proceeded to discuss New York City, Shanghai and Toronto. He talked about New York City being the capital of
the 20th century. An idea that connects with the ‘spacialisation of time’ suggested by the third quote by Lefebvre. He
spoke of Shanghai as the city of tomorrow and of its tremendous population (22 million). Kingwell used Toronto to
discuss how climate effects build forms. He defined the sum of the Canadian national character: “…as trying to get as far
away from the weather as possible (moving south) without becoming Americans”.
A few other interesting points that he raised were:
humans have created more concrete than any other man-made thing
for a statue or building or what-have-you to become a monument it must reorganise the psycho-geography of the city;
and
He spoke about the grid system of New York City as a "screen through which we force the aspirations of capital."
Donna Campbell, a lecturer in Maori material culture, indigenous textile creation and Maori art history at the University of
Waikato, New Zealand, spoke on indigenous collaborations in the fiber arts and told the story of ‘The Eternal Thread
Exhibition’. The exhibition featured Maori textiles that traveled to the western part of the United States as part of a
collaboration with the Native Americans of the Northwestern United States. She also talked about the bounds that were
formed between the different tribes across continents because of this exhibition. Read more about Donna Campbell
Delaware provided ample entertainment during the last presentation of the day. Delaware is a Japanese ‘super sonic
group’ who designs music and ‘musics’ design. They define themselves as ‘artoonists’, meaning art plus cartoon. Their
work takes on multiple forms such as recordings, visual installation, writing, web, mobile phone, poster, cross stitch, and
live performance. Delaware’s presentation took the form of a multimedia performance that utilised pre-recorded words
and music as well as text typed and then read by various computerised voices as the sole means of verbal communication between the presenters and the audience. They introduced a project that is an application for the iPhone
that looks and functions like a turntable, complete with scratch and mixing options. Read more about Delaware
Day five of Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week ended with an Icograda Regional Meeting and the launch of Adobe’s
CS4 in the Gulf region.
Contributors: Samara Watkiss and Priya D'Souza (VCUQatar)
The unquestionable highlight of the Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week featured the final keynote speaker, Mira Nair
one of Hollywood’s most accomplished and award-winning directors. Her successes include ‘Salaam Bombay!’ – her
debut feature which was nominated for an Academy Award, Golden Globe, and BAFTA Award for Best Foreign Language
Film – ‘Mississippi Masala’, ‘Monsoon Wedding’, ‘Kama Sutra: A Tale of Love’, ‘My Own Country’, and ‘Vanity Fair’. Nair’s
presentation began with short video montage of clips from her feature film, ‘The Namesake’.
Nair grew up in Delhi and referred to herself as one of the "post-colonial children". She explained that her first inspiration
came from Jathra folk theater, which describes the great struggles of good and evil. From this type of theatre she learned
that what is required to create a great narrative is "vision and passion and great drama," and not necessarily a big
Hollywood budget. She also said, about her process, that she looks for issues that get under her skin. Several times
during the lecture she said that she is not interested in teaching people about her country. She enigmatically claimed: "to
be a cultural ambassador is quite boring." She is also not interested in being an anthropologist: "I can't bare anthropology
in my films."
Nair continued to articulate her driving philosophy, which is particularly relevant in relationship to the ongoing discussion
of globalisation at the Mousharaka conference – the more local a story is, the more universal. "Specificity is my
treasure," she said. Nair contrasted her focus on locality to what she called the "Euro-pudding" approach to film making.
For example, a film with an American star actress, and British actor faking a German accent filmed in some unnamed
European country. She said that although this attempts to ‘please everyone’, she believes the audiences never really buy
it. In her film ‘Monsoon Wedding’, three languages are spoken and she did not subtitle any of it because she did not want
to pander to a particular (English speaking) audience. She also said that the actors' expression, the jocularity, should
express what might not be understood through language. She stated that people all around the world felt like the family
in ‘Monsoon Wedding’ was their family because of the specificity of that particular culture.
Nair also spoke about her process of directing films, saying that she creates a binder filled with images that suggest the
feeling of each scene she is planning to film. She gives this binder to her crew many weeks before the filming
commences. She does this so when she is actually filming, she does not have to talk very much. She said this allows her
to focus and remain porous to the inspiration of the moment.
Nair addressed the students in the audience particularly, and offered her advice or ‘little mantras’ for working creatively:
Never treat anything as a stepping-stone. Give yourself fully to every project and do not see it merely as a means to
an end.
Practice BKS Iyengar’s Yoga, to be brave even when it means being lonely as happens with artists most times.
The heart should inform the brain. Allow inspiration to come from anywhere.
Beware the fruits of action. Don't focus too much and rewards of your work, they can be confusing and distract you
from your art.
She also advised that the best collaborator is not always the person with the best C.V. but someone with whom you have
a creative synergy.
The presentation ended with the second ever screening of ‘8’, a six-minute short that addresses the UN Millennium goal
of Gender Equality. The beautiful and jarring film tells the morally ambiguous tale of a Muslim woman leaving her
husband and young son to become the second wife of another man, with whom she is in love. Read more about Mira Nair at (www.mirabaifilms.com)
The Professional Conference concluded with an interactive panel discussion and lunch at the Souq where delegates had
one final opportunity to interact with the impressive list of talented speakers.
Delegates were unanimous in commenting on their experiences of the past six days. The quality and diversity of all the
presentations were consistently excellent, providing ample food for thought and a visual feast for the eye. Delegates left
invigorated and inspired.
The Mousharaka: Icograda Design Week, Qatar, ended with a gala dinner at the Srahq Village and Spa. The
entertainment for the evening was a fashion show presented by VUQatar alumna and budding entrepreneur, Sara
Nasser Abdulghany’s Sara’s Secrets. Guests got a glimpse of Arabian fashion from an original Qatari point of view and a
reflection of the designer’s personality. The fabrics were rich, luxurious and epitomised everything exquisite, artistic and
truly Arabesque, with names that could have been picked straight out of the Arabian Nights.
About Icograda
Icograda (the International Council of Graphic Design Associations) is the world body for professional communication
design. Founded in 1963 in London, UK, it is a voluntary assembly of organisations concerned with graphic design,
visual communication, design management, promotion, education, research and journalism. Icograda promotes
communication designers' vital role in society and commerce and unifies the voices of graphic designers and visual
communicators worldwide. For more information visit www.icograda.org
About Virginia Commonwealth University in Qatar:
Established in the USA in 1838 and in Qatar in 1998, Virginia Commonwealth University offers students from all over the
world the opportunity to earn Bachelor of Fine Arts degrees in fashion, graphic and interior design. A team of highly
skilled professors provide rigorous curricula that prepare students to assume leadership roles in the professional design
field of their choice. VCUQatar regularly organises and hosts exhibitions, gallery events, world-class conferences and
holds an annual fashion show. VCUQatar is supported and funded by the Qatar Foundation. For more information visit www.qatar.vcu.edu
About Qatar Foundation for Education, Science and Community Development
Founded in 1995 by His Highness Sheikh Hamad Bin Khalifa Al Thani, Emir of Qatar, and chaired by Her Highness
Sheikha Mozah Bint Nasser Al Missned, Qatar Foundation is a private, non-profit organisation committed to the principle
that the nation’s greatest natural resource is its people. The headquarters of Qatar Foundation are located within its
flagship project, Education City, a fourteen million square-meter campus which hosts numerous progressive learning
institutions and centers of research, including branch campuses of six of the world’s leading universities, plus a cuttingedge
research and development center. Qatar Foundation also works to enhance the quality of life in Qatar by investing
in community health and development. For more information visit www.qf.org.qa
Images by Marcus Elblaus
From Top to Bottom:
Mira Nair speaking at the Professional Conference.
Mark Kingwell, Meera Nair and Dr Sami Angawi engaging in the panel discussion at the Professional Conference.
A view of the gala dinner at the Srahq Village and Spa.
Models displaying outfit from the Sara's Secrets collection.